Step 14: tool results

add_argument

{
  "name": "The corrigibility basin-of-attraction argument",
  "stance": "for",
  "claim_id": "aada82ab-4dce-496e-986c-ec721c66704d",
  "description": "A system that defers to its overseers' preferences, even if it knows them only approximately, wants its successors to track those preferences better, so approximate alignment is self-correcting across generations."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The corrigibility basin-of-attraction argument\" (for) on claim aada82ab-4dce-496e-986c-ec721c66704d. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"bf15a85a-495b-4830-9428-a01a107eee88"}

add_argument

{
  "name": "The argument from inherited flaws",
  "stance": "against",
  "claim_id": "aada82ab-4dce-496e-986c-ec721c66704d",
  "description": "Where the approximation lies in what the system values or in hidden dispositions, the system has no motive to remove the flaw and its flaws can pass undetected to successors it trains or supervises."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The argument from inherited flaws\" (against) on claim aada82ab-4dce-496e-986c-ec721c66704d. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"32fb1b38-bfd0-4cae-a645-f3f263786b45"}