Run step
Step 24: tool results
evaluate_argument
Input
{
"verdict": "likely",
"decisive": false,
"evaluation": "Suppose AuditBench and similar testbeds are representative of agent-based auditing. Then the best black-box affordances leading every white-box tool on every target configuration makes the claim much more likely. The lead belongs to the scaffolded variants: unscaffolded black-box tools score about the same as white-box tools on average. The inference also rests on whether one weak investigator (Claude Haiku 4.5) and artificially implanted behaviours stand in for auditing in general. That premise is untested, and the paper's own tool-to-agent gap analysis puts it in doubt.",
"argument_id": "d8ea5982-ca7f-4102-b2e1-d25c7a440b07"
}{"success":true,"message":"Evaluation recorded for argument \"The argument from AuditBench and secret-elicitation tool comparisons\": likely."}evaluate_argument
Input
{
"verdict": "slight",
"decisive": false,
"evaluation": "Even if the premises hold, the argument shows only that white-box tools beat basic chat access in one testbed. That testbed had no scaffolded black-box condition, and its interpretability advantage partly came from a sparse autoencoder trained on data containing the planted documents. It shows that the ordering depends on the setting. It does not show that white-box tools beat the strongest black-box tools.",
"argument_id": "851336c7-7768-4848-9448-3179bfa582a6"
}{"success":true,"message":"Evaluation recorded for argument \"The argument from the Marks et al. auditing game, where interpretability tools were key\": slight."}set_claim_importance
Input
{
"claim_id": "86063716-4ef1-48dc-abe6-02ef8b75f176",
"reasoning": "This bears on how alignment-auditing and interpretability research is prioritised and on how much weight interpretability gets in safety cases. The evidence base is small and the result is actively discussed, so major-to-notable.",
"importance": 0.55,
"contestation": 0.5
}{"success":true,"message":"Importance of claim 86063716-4ef1-48dc-abe6-02ef8b75f176 set to 0.55. Contestation recorded as 0.5."}