steward run 62e3c681

Setup

Claude Opus 5.5 claude-opus-5-5 · up to 16384 tokens a turn

• constitution constitution v8
• role claim-steward v8
• tool search_similar_claims v1
• tool get_claim v10
• tool get_claim_instances v2
• tool get_contribution_details v2
• tool get_claim_dependents v1
• tool read_page v2
• tool view_image v1
• tool read_arxiv_source v1
• tool update_claim_assessment v1
• tool record_claim_instance v3
• tool update_claim_instance v1
• tool detach_claim_instance v1
• tool reattach_claim_instance v1
• tool set_instance_order v1
• tool update_canonical_form v1
• tool add_argument v1
• tool write_argument v1
• tool evaluate_argument v1
• tool add_relationship_edge v1
• tool add_related_claim v1
• tool add_decomposition_edge v1
• tool add_parent_claim v1
• tool propose_parent_edge v1
• tool set_claim_importance v1
• tool set_claim_domains v1
• tool log_stewardship_decision v1
• tool notify_steward v1
• tool escalate_to_curator v5
• tool remove_subclaim_edge v1
• tool set_edge_relation v1
• tool ungroup_subclaim v1
• tool revise_argument v1
• tool retire_argument v1
• tool record_argument_instance v3
• tool place_argument_passage v1
• tool answer_messages v1
• tool read_message v1
• tool commission v7
• tool petition_mandate v3
• tool wait_for_answers v2
• tool query_sql v2
• tool set_quantity_definition v1
• tool record_estimate v2
• tool update_quantity_estimate v1
• tool record_quantity_reading v2
• tool set_argument_shows v1
• tool record_cut v1
• tool file_request v2
• tool list_requests v2
• tool revise_request v1
• tool close_request v1
• tool get_source_context v1
• tool match_claim v3
• tool load_skill v1
• tool cost_sheet v1
• tool lean_search v1
• tool lean_elaborate v1
• tool lean_check v1
• tool publish_formalization v1
• tool get_proof_attempt v1
• tool mark_problem_solved_by_platform v1
• tool get_prize_claim v1
• tool decide_prize_claim v1
• tool provenance_get_map v6
• tool provenance_read_source v2
• tool provenance_record_reading v7
• tool provenance_record_edge v6
• tool provenance_record_source_relationship v1
• tool provenance_record_root v1
• tool provenance_write_map v1
• tool provenance_cite_findings v1
• tool record_source_interest v1
• tool get_research_run v1
• tool raise_issue v1
• tool update_issue v1
• tool search_issues v1
• tool get_issue v2
• tool note_finding v7
• tool search_findings v1
• tool web_search v1
• tool code_execution v1

Steps

0. prompt Setup: claude-opus-5-5, 81 tool(s). Opening: You have been triggered to steward a claim. Today's date: 2026-11-15 Trigger: consistency_flag Claim ID: ce83c0f0-e756-…
1. assistant calls get_claim [tool_use]
2. tool results get_claim returned: {"claim":{"id":"ce83c0f0-e756-4e41-89d8-86d2f16dc9c3","kind":"claim","canonical_form":"Current AI systems can reliably …
3. assistant calls read_page [tool_use]
4. tool results read_page returned: {"ok":true,"url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.20803","text":"[2506.20803] The Ideation-Execution Gap: Execution Outcomes…
5. assistant calls set_edge_relation, get_claim [tool_use]
6. tool results set_edge_relation, get_claim returned: {"success":true,"message":"The edge from ce83c0f0-e756-4e41-89d8-86d2f16dc9c3 to 2e6a6348-a373-48b5-b7fa-f26a3c3342c5 s…
7. assistant "Now record the revised assessment."; calls update_claim_assessment, answer_messages, log_stewardship_decision [tool_use]
8. tool results update_claim_assessment, answer_messages, log_stewardship_decision returned: {"success":true,"message":"Assessment updated for claim ce83c0f0-e756-4e41-89d8-86d2f16dc9c3: doubtful (0.6)"}
9. assistant "The verdict stays the same: the claim that current AI systems reliably generate novel experimental hypotheses that survive validation is still **doubtful**. Th…" [end_turn]