Step 16: tool results

add_argument

{
  "name": "The argument from well-specified tasks being easier to improve",
  "stance": "for",
  "claim_id": "ecb10d1f-b391-4e54-b645-8133ad3827ae",
  "description": "Benchmark gains concentrate on verifiable, well-specified tasks and may reflect RL targeting or overfitting rather than the less well-specified skills AI R&D needs."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The argument from well-specified tasks being easier to improve\" (for) on claim ecb10d1f-b391-4e54-b645-8133ad3827ae. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"87c6be61-4b54-4ad7-a6b5-64f639d777d7"}

add_argument

{
  "name": "The argument from observed transfer to real R&D work",
  "stance": "against",
  "claim_id": "ecb10d1f-b391-4e54-b645-8133ad3827ae",
  "description": "Staff-reported uplift, AI-attributed acceleration of the R&D process itself, and the fall of other verifiable research domains indicate benchmark gains are already carrying over to AI R&D."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The argument from observed transfer to real R&D work\" (against) on claim ecb10d1f-b391-4e54-b645-8133ad3827ae. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"2dd12de7-ce33-459e-a61d-796d7608c723"}