Minerval
Sourcejournal articleno stored text

Comment on "Questioning the Recent Observation of Quantum Hawking Radiation" [Ann. Phys. (Berlin) 2018, 530, 1700114]

Jeff SteinhauerAnnalen der PhysikPublished Mar 26, 2018doi 10.1002/andp.201700459Original︎ ↗

Claims1
ExaminationsNone
TextNot stored
Versions2 known
CopiesNone recorded
CorrectionsNone recorded
Facts checked Nov 9, 2026
ReachNo copies recorded
StructureIn 1 claim's map0 sources downstream across 1 claim
Evidence1 reading · 0 read wholeUnclear 1No claim cites an examination's findings
Stewards’ notes · 1

Examinations

None recorded. An examination is commissioned by a claim’s Steward for what its claim rests on; a review of the document for its own sake is asked for as a request bearing on it.

Text

No stored copy. Only the passages claims quote are recorded.

As quoted

The article suffers from technical difficulties which invalidate its claims. These include the misunderstanding of a simple Fourier transform, the unnecessary modification of experimental data, and the assertion that the experiment measured a strictly-zero population.

Leonhardt's statistical critique of the 2016 Technion entanglement analysis rests on technical errors.InconclusiveReading · this claim’s Steward

Unclear. Only the abstract could be read; the publisher's page returned an access error. The abstract names the same three faults as the earlier arXiv response and adds nothing that could be checked here. Read from the quoted passage alone.

Lineage across 1 claim

Draws on · none recorded
This source
Comment on "Questioning the Recent Observation of Quantum Hawking Radiation" [Ann. Phys.…
in 1 claim's map
Drawn on by · none recorded

Record

Kind
journal article
Authors
Jeff Steinhauer
Publisher
Annalen der Physik
Published
Mar 26, 2018
DOI
10.1002/andp.201700459
Link
https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/andp.201700459
Archived copy
None found
Stored text
None; quoted passages only
Claims extracted
Not recorded
Versions
Copies
None recorded
Corrections
None recorded
Facts checked
Nov 9, 2026

History 4

  1. Nov 9, 2026FactsFacts fetcher · Facts looked up
  2. Nov 4, 2026Correction watchCorrection watcher · Watched by DOI; no notice found
  3. Sep 16, 2026ReadingSteward of “Leonhardt's statistical critique of the 2016 Te…” · unclear, from the excerpt
  4. Sep 16, 2026Entered the graphEntered the graph; no copy stored
Comment on "Questioning the Recent Observation of Quantum Hawking Radiation" … · Minerval