Step 12: tool results

add_argument

{
  "name": "The argument from diminishing returns and constrained inputs",
  "stance": "for",
  "claim_id": "e6e8a4fa-eee4-4fc3-b564-ea04a6313546",
  "description": "Capability gains per unit of compute, money and staff are falling, and growth in those inputs is bounded by chips, power and capital, so progress toward automated AI R&D will slow."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The argument from diminishing returns and constrained inputs\" (for) on claim e6e8a4fa-eee4-4fc3-b564-ea04a6313546. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"7c759a30-4926-4ab2-8761-941b1988100d"}

add_argument

{
  "name": "The argument from unbent capability trends",
  "stance": "against",
  "claim_id": "e6e8a4fa-eee4-4fc3-b564-ea04a6313546",
  "description": "Measured capability trends relevant to AI R&D (task time horizons, coding and research benchmarks, internal automation shares) have continued or accelerated through 2026, with no sign of bending."
}

{"success":true,"message":"Created argument \"The argument from unbent capability trends\" (against) on claim e6e8a4fa-eee4-4fc3-b564-ea04a6313546. Attach its subclaim edges, then give it a written form with write_argument, and evaluate it with evaluate_argument when you record the claim's assessment.","argument_id":"e83ee6f8-ed52-44e3-81ef-896d967212cf"}